What’s a tasting worth? Part 1 – Before you sign the contract.
Ask questions. Can you make changes? Do menus change seasonally? Will your dish be as you have seen it, or are the vegetable and starch “chef’s choice”? How do they accommodate special requests, such as vegetarian or Kosher? How long has the chef been with the venue, and will he be on site for your wedding? If not, who will? What are the wine options? If it is “house”, you will want to know what that is. And you should take notes, and recap the note in future correspondence to the venue.
Reputation. But you want to make sure that the reputation is based on the kinds of experiences that you are looking for (a restaurant that is know of as the best in town does not mean that it can replicate the experience on a banquet scale.)
Search the web and blogs. Try to find other people who have had weddings there (newspaper wedding announcements usually mention where the wedding occurred.) Don’t depend only on references provided by the venue.
Look for clues outside of the “sales cycle.” Visit the venue discretely. Are the rest of the staff eager to assist? Are people smiling? This will tell you a lot about the venue’s culture. Perhaps the sales person is charming and professional, but don’t forget the snooty receptionist.
Once you have done all of that, trust your instincts, make a decision, and be thrilled with the decision you have made!
Next: Part 2 – After the contract is signed.